|
The First Art Newspaper on the Net |
|
Established in 1996 |
|
Sunday, October 6, 2024 |
|
On the 150th Birthday of Its Discovery, Famed Fossil Isn't a Bird After All, Analysis Says |
|
|
the fossilized skeleton of what scientists at the Chinese Academy of Sciences in Beijing are dubbing "Xiaotingia zhengi." Its discovery helped scientists propose an evolutionary tree that suggests archaeopteryx is not a bird. AP Photo/Nature.
By: Malcolm Ritter, AP Science Writer
|
NEW YORK (AP).- One of the world's most famous fossil creatures, widely considered the earliest known bird, is getting a rude present on the 150th birthday of its discovery: A new analysis suggests it isn't a bird at all.
Chinese scientists are proposing a change to the evolutionary family tree that boots Archaeopteryx off the "bird" branch and onto a closely related branch of birdlike dinosaurs.
Archaeopteryx (ahr-kee-AHP'-teh-rihx) was a crow-sized creature that lived about 150 million years ago. It had wings and feathers, but also quite un-birdlike traits like teeth and a bony tail. Discovered in 1861 in Germany, two years after Charles Darwin published "On the Origin of Species," it quickly became an icon for evolution and has remained popular since.
The Chinese scientists acknowledge they have only weak evidence to support their proposal, which hinges on including a newly recognized dinosaur.
Other experts say the change could easily be reversed by further discoveries. And while it might shake scientific understanding within the bird lineage, they said, it doesn't make much difference for some other evolutionary questions.
Archaeopteryx dwells in a section of the family tree that's been reshuffled repeatedly over the past 15 or 20 years and still remains murky. It contains the small, two-legged dinosaurs that took the first steps toward flight. Fossil discoveries have blurred the distinction between dinosaurlike birds and birdlike dinosaurs, with traits such as feathers and wishbones no longer seen as reliable guides.
"Birds have been so embedded within this group of small dinosaurs ... it's very difficult to tell who is who," said Lawrence Witmer of Ohio University, who studies early bird evolution but didn't participate in the new study.
The proposed reclassification of Archaeopteryx wouldn't change the idea that birds arose from this part of the tree, he said, but it could make scientists reevaluate what they think about evolution within the bird lineage itself.
"Much of what we've known about the early evolution of birds has in a sense been filtered through Archaeopteryx," Witmer said. "Archaeopteryx has been the touchstone... (Now) the centerpiece for many of those hypotheses may or may not be part of that lineage."
The new analysis is presented in Thursday's issue of the journal Nature by Xing Xu of the Chinese Academy of Sciences in Beijing, and colleagues. They compared 384 specific anatomical traits of 89 species to figure out how the animals were related. The result was a tree that grouped Archaeopteryx with deinonychosaurs, two-legged meat-eaters that are evolutionary cousins to birds.
But that result appeared only when the analysis included a previously unknown dinosaur that's similar to Archaeopteryx, which the researchers dubbed Xiaotingia zhengi. It was about the size of a chicken when it lived some 160 million years ago in the Liaoning province of China, home to many feathered dinosaurs and early birds.
Julia Clarke of the University of Texas at Austin, who did not participate in the study, said the reclassification appeared to be justified by the current data. But she emphasized the study dealt with a poorly understood section of the evolutionary tree, and that more fossil discoveries could very well shift Archaeopteryx back to the "bird" branch.
Anyway, moving it "a couple of branches" isn't a huge change, and whether it's considered a bird or not is mostly a semantic issue that doesn't greatly affect larger questions about the origin of flight, she said.
Luis Chiappe, an expert in early bird evolution at the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County who wasn't part of the new study, said he doesn't think the evidence is very solid.
"I feel this needs to be reassessed by other people, and I'm sure it will be," he said.
Malcolm Ritter can be followed at http://www.twitter.com/malcolmritter
Copyright 2011 The Associated Press.
|
|
Today's News
July 28, 2011
On the 150th Birthday of Its Discovery, Famed Fossil Isn't a Bird After All, Analysis Says
Sotheby's Announces September Sale of The Philatelic Collection of Lord Steinberg
Art for the Nation: Acquisitions Made by Sir Charles Eastlake on View at the National Gallery
Line and Space: American Drawing and Sculptures Since 1960 at the Pinakothek der Moderne
At the Birthplace of Modernism, A Rebirth; Cranbrook Art Museum to Reopen in November
Sigmund Freud Museum in London Celebrates 25th Anniversary on Thursday
Gilbert 'Magu' Lujan, Colorful and Expressive Chicano Movement Artist, Dies at 70
'Snapshot' Exhibition at Van Gogh Museum will Zoom in on Artists' Everyday Lives
The Museum of Modern Art Announces a Change in Admission Prices; $25 for Adults
Martha Stewart, Macy's CEO and a High-End Fashion Designer Studying Haiti Crafts
The Textile Museum Joins the George Washington University; New Museum to Open in Mid-2014
LeConte Stewart: One Artist, Two Exhibitions, Over 200 Works at the Utah Museum of Fine Arts
New Publication Explores History Behind Monet's Water Lilies Triptych: Agapanthus
Indiana's Rag Tops Auto Museum Collection to Be Offered at Auctions America by RM's Auburn Fall Sale
New Display Explores Influential, but Somewhat Forgotten Socialist Herbert Morrison
Key Works Completed Over the Course of Manny Farber's Painting Career at Quint Contemporary Art
New Site-Specific Project by William Powhida Opens at Marlborough's Chelsea Gallery
Art History UK Offers More in-Depth and Intimate Alternative to the Mass-Market Tourist Tours
Atheist Group Sues Over Cross at Sept. 11 Museum
Philly Historic Warship Gets Damaged Hull Patched
Hit UFO Image was Polystyrene, Says Forger
Call-To-Arms for Support of the Artist's Resale Right's Full Implementation
|
|
|
|
|
Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography, Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs, Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, . |
|
|
|
Royalville Communications, Inc produces:
|
|
|
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful
|
|