The First Art Newspaper on the Net   Established in 1996 Thursday, November 26, 2020

Tainted by Nazism? Merkel returns two Nolde paintings
A visitor passes the entrance to the exhibition of German painter Emil Nolde (1867-1956) at the Hamburger Bahnhof museum in Berlin on April 12, 2019. Chancellor Angela Merkel's decision to strip two paintings by Emil Nolde from her office walls has touched off a heated German debate as an exhibition on the Expressionist painter and his links to the Nazis opened in Berlin. Tobias SCHWARZ / AFP.

by Hui Min Neo

BERLIN (AFP).- Chancellor Angela Merkel's decision to take down two paintings by Emil Nolde from her office walls has touched off a heated German debate as an exhibition on the Expressionist painter and his links to the Nazis opened in Berlin.

Organisers of the show "Emil Nolde, a German Legend: The Artist During National Socialism," had asked Merkel for one of two paintings on loan to her.

But she decided to send both -- a 1915 painting of flowers in a garden and the 1936 work "Breakers", her spokesman Steffen Seibert said.

No explanation was given for the decision. Neither was an official reason offered as to why Merkel would not want them back when the exhibition closes in September.

But the move was quickly interpreted by German media as a belated rejection by Merkel of the artist over his anti-Semitic views and entanglement with Adolf Hitler's Nazi regime.

Amid the controversy, Seibert said Merkel had been offered two other paintings by the Prussian Cultural Heritage Foundation.

But after historians quickly pointed out that the concerned artist, Karl Schmidt-Rottluff, was also known for his anti-Semitic comments, and Merkel simply decided to put off the decorating for a while.

"The chancellor decided not to borrow any other pictures from the Prussian Cultural Heritage Foundation for her office," a spokesman said.

The episode has unleashed a round of soul-searching over what kind of place an artist's moral values should have on the way his works are viewed or portrayed.

'Panicky reaction'
Nolde was long cast in the post-war years as a victim of Hitler's regime because his art was condemned by the Nazis as "degenerate" and removed from museums.

But research has shown he was a vocal anti-Semite and fervent supporter of the Third Reich.

At the exhibition of Nolde's works which opened Thursday at Berlin's Hamburger Bahnhof museum, curators Aya Soika and Bernhard Fulda sought to dispel the myths surrounding Nolde's persona, putting on full display his anti-Jewish views alongside his works.

Fulda conceded that he was "slightly surprised" by Merkel's decision to return the two paintings.

"There is a way you can use the complex and difficult and indeed negative German past to say 'it's still relevant today, and we're not just looking the other way'," he said.

But he acknowledged that such parsing may not be a priority for a leader who is battling global crises on multiple fronts.

Writer Florian Illies, in Die Zeit weekly, also said it would been more productive to "give space to the truth, that mean-spirited people can also make high art."

"It is of course uncomfortable. But much more courageous than starting again to remove paintings from the walls."

Thole Rotermund, the treasurer of Germany's federation of galleries and art traders, told news agency DPA that Merkel should give a clear explanation for her decision.

If Nolde is being shunned because of his political views, "then she should no longer be sitting in the first row" at the Bayreuth opera festival which Merkel attends annually and which features the works of notorious anti-Semite Richard Wagner.

For Christian Ring, the director of the Seebuell Ada and Emil Nolde Foundation, the debate that has erupted over the artist "is very, very exciting".

"I think it is right that people are talking about it, and that people are analysing the situation and discussing it.

"That's something I find more important than what's been removed from the walls or not removed. And that's what we're trying to do with this exhibition -- we want a discussion, how should we navigate this vis-a-vis our moral compass," he said.

Merkel's office too, "must develop its own view on what art should be presented in the chancellery," he said.

One thing was certain though -- Merkel's decision would go down in history as an "anecdote to show how after so many years, ... Hitler... still generates so much interest that is difficult to ignore," predicted Fulda.

"And that's why you get this panicky reaction."

© Agence France-Presse

Today's News

April 13, 2019

Tainted by Nazism? Merkel returns two Nolde paintings

Tourists stunned as Notre-Dame cathedral statues fly above Paris

Bruce Museum names Robert Wolterstorff as new Executive Director

Christie's to offer works from the Collection of H.S.H. Princess 'Titi' von Fürstenberg

New works by Sean Scully unveiled as part of a major exhibition at the National Gallery

Victoria Miro presents selected portraits from a series begun in January 2018 by Chantal Joffe's

Museum 'considering options' after discovering Bolsonaro date

Museum of Contemporary Art Chicago opens an exhibition of works by Jonathas de Andrade

The Drawing Center opens Neo Rauch's first exhibition entirely devoted to his drawings in the U.S.

Sprüth Magers, Los Angeles opens an exhibition of new paintings by George Condo

Most comprehensive exhibition to date of the work of Philippe Vandenberg opens at The Kunsthaus Pasquart

On April 28, The Bill Drake Collection of Model Trains goes up for bid

No Patience for Monuments: Exhibition at Perrotin Seoul brings together the work of a dozen artists

Mike Kelley Foundation for the Arts awards $400,000 to ten Los Angeles arts organizations

Shannon's to offer lots by European, American and Asian artists

Powerful work by Nelson Mandela to be offered at Bonhams African Art Sale in New York

'Green Places/Green Spaces/Greenhouses' opens at the Cape Ann Museum

The Robin Rice Gallery opens a photographic exhibition by Micheal McLaughlin

The Bass opens a solo exhibition of two-and three-dimensional textile works by Sheila Hicks

A series by the late artist Theo Wujcik features larger-than-life paintings inspired by Dante's Inferno

National Portrait Gallery unveils newly commissioned portraits of leading film directors

AIPAD's Photography Show 2019: Record-breaking attendance, strong reviews

Stunning new Tiffany Lamp arrives at Lyman Allyn Art Museum

Exhibition of new sculptures and works on paper by Charles Ray opens at Matthew Marks

Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .


Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez

Royalville Communications, Inc
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
to a Mexican poet.

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful