Holocaust 'masterpiece' causes uproar at Venice film festival

The First Art Newspaper on the Net    Established in 1996 Saturday, April 20, 2024


Holocaust 'masterpiece' causes uproar at Venice film festival
Canadian actor Barry Pepper poses during the photocall for the movie "The Painted Bird" of Czech director Vaclav Marhoul, presented in competition on September 3, 2019 during the 76th Venice Film Festival at Venice Lido. Alberto PIZZOLI / AFP.

by Fiachra Gibbons



VENICE (AFP).- A searing adaptation of one of most controversial books about the Holocaust divided critics at the Venice film festival Wednesday, with some fighting each other in the dark to get out of its first screening.

"The Painted Bird", based on Jerzy Kosinski's highly contentious 1965 novel about a Jewish boy surviving the worst human nature can inflict on him in an unnamed Eastern European country, was hailed as a masterpiece by some and an unwatchable ordeal by others.

But its staggering central performance from nine-year-old Czech Roma boy Petr Kotlar -- who witnesses a panoply of depravity from incest, bestiality and rape to mutilation and murder -- has had co-stars Harvey Keitel and Stellan Skarsgard as well as the critics in raptures.

That did not stop some running for the exits at its first screening.

In the very first scene, the boy's pet ferret is taken from him by boorish peasants and burned alive.

The Hollywood Reporter called the black-and-white epic "heart-wrenching... and the ideal film treatment" of the novel, which itself sparked outrage in Kosinski's native Poland when the writer first hinted that the story was autobiographical.

'Monumental work'
The Guardian's Xan Brooks also heaped praise on Czech director Vaclav Marhoul for "never putting a foot wrong", adding: "One day they'll make a film about the first public screening" at Venice.

"It will feature the man who fell full-length on the steps in his effort to escape and the well-dressed woman who became so frantic to get out that she hit the stranger in the next seat," he wrote.

"The centrepiece will be the moment 12 viewers broke for the doors only to discover that the exit had been locked," he added.

Brooks declared the film "a monumental piece of work and one I'm deeply glad to have seen. I can also say I hope to never cross its path again."

Deborah Young of The Hollywood Reporter also hailed it, but warned that it was an "emotional three-hour punch in the stomach".

Marhoul defended the unremitting darkness of his adaptation -- which has a happy ending, of sorts -- insisting that "only in darkness can we see light. Shining through all the horrors is, for me, hope and love."

He said the film was a warning of what can happen when Europe turns inward as it was doing now, drawing a parallel between the attitudes to migrant children fleeing wars in Syria, Libya and Afghanistan and the rejection and abuse his hero suffers.

'Kosinski lied'
"Bad times are coming to Europe," he told reporters.

"Looking at the populists who are running so many European countries at the moment like Hungary, Poland, Russia, in the Czech Republic too and of course the US."

Marhoul said the film took 11 years to make.

"I didn't know when I started that this story would become much more accented by what happened in Europe three years ago, when so many people came here to save their lives," he said.

Because of the fury Kosinski sparked in Poland, the director decided to have most of the film's sparse dialogue in Slavic Esperanto "so no nation would be associated with villagers" who mistreat the boy and hand him over to the Nazis.

Despite being accused of plagiarising other Polish books, Kosinski's novel is still seen by many as a classic.

"When Kosinski said it was his autobiographical story he was lying," Marhoul said.

"In fact he spent the World War II with his parents among Polish villagers. And those villagers tried to save them... That's not a big problem for the book (because it is fiction). But many people in Poland still think this book is about them."

© Agence France-Presse










Today's News

September 5, 2019

McNay Art Museum breaks ground on $6.25 million landscape master plan

Phoenix Art Museum celebrates 550th anniversary of the birth of Sikhism's founder with new exhibition

Mexican National Art Museum presents a selection of 70 pencil and charcoal drawings, made by Dr. Atl

Katherine Martin named new Chairman of Asia Week New York

Peter Lindbergh, revolutionary fashion photographer, dies at 74

Hitler bust found in cellar of French Senate

Art exhibition celebrates Wilson College's sesquicentennial works by Jim Condron

Aztec ballgame returns to Mexico City after 500 years

Boathouse yields trove from forgotten artist

Imperial Chinese £1 charity shop find to bring £50,000

Slovenian village divided over Trump 'statue of liberty'

The Fondation d'entreprise Hermès opens a solo show by French artist Camille Blatrix

Museum of Arts and Design appoints Elissa Auther as Deputy Director of Curatorial Affairs & Chief Curator

Bolivia's fires destroy 'heritage' rock art sites

Nationalmuseum presents an exhibition of the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989

Kasmin announces US representation of Ali Banisadr

Holocaust 'masterpiece' causes uproar at Venice film festival

Indian plus-size actors defy stereotypes with bold theatre

Berlin's Kulturforum opens a group exhibition of media art from China

£10 million project set to make Luton vital arts hub

Beatrice Leanza is the new Executive Director of Lisbon's Museum of Art, Architecture and Technology

Peter Aaron's photographs show a lost Syria

Kennedy's visit to meet survivors cared for in Glasgow captured in archive collection exhibition

The Lumiere Brothers Center for Photography opens a retrospective exhibition of Vladimir Lagrange's work




Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 



Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org juncodelavega.com facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful