What Agile framework should we choose?

The First Art Newspaper on the Net    Established in 1996 Tuesday, March 19, 2024


What Agile framework should we choose?



As an expert software development team that designs the most complicated software solutions for our customers, we always face a choice which Agile framework we should choose. Some tasks can be easily solved by SCRUM, sometimes Kanban provides us with the optimal solutions. Let’s go deeper to find the answer to the question, what framework to choose.

SCRUM or Kanban
The most well-known and widely used Agile frameworks are SCRUM and Kanban. SCRUM suggests we work on the development of the project iteratively. At the end of each iteration, which lasts about a couple of weeks, we have the finished simple version of the software product that we can deliver to the customer. Before starting the first iteration, which is called Sprint, our team of developers has to assign roles and plan thoroughly these two weeks and then, during a Sprint, meet daily to organize essential interaction within the team. Since it is an Agile framework, we should insert modifications according to customers’ feedback and changes in an environment. However, here we are allowed to do it only between Sprints, and no changes can be made within one iteration.

As for Kanban, its main idea is to put all the issues together, and use a board with columns called “to do”, “in progress” and “done” to systematize the development tasks. Here we visualize our issues with stickers and put them in the column that corresponds to the status of the task. In Kanban we have no roles for our team members, they are all equivalent. Moreover, any changes can be inserted at any time and anyone from our team, or from the client’s side can suggest them. So, this framework, on the one hand, is much more flexible, but, on the other hand, contains some hidden problems such as it has no exact time when the product will be ready and the project is completed.

Some hybrid methods as Scrumban propose us to use a combination of these two approaches, such as iterative work, where Sprint is organized according to Kanban principles.

So, when should we prefer using the first one, and when does the second one fit much better? Or should we choose Scrumban and other hybrids?

Is SCRUM the right thing to choose?
SCRUM is a great option when a customer has no exact understanding of the market needs and wishes to be flexible with the software changes, providing regular feedback about further improvements and functional and non-functional demands. In this case, we can accurately estimate the work to do and the team is able to work cooperatively. However, there are multiple requirements that our team and project need to meet to work in SCRUM workflow productively.

Let’s look at an example of the data science project. Here we have a concrete set of tasks to be done, from point one, setting the hypothesis, choosing the models, and training them to the final step, when we have to choose the best working model and finalize the work with the whole database, collecting the results. Here is nothing about SCRUM iterations or KanBan ToDos. It’s a structured Waterfall process. All in all, data science projects are just one of the examples where SCRUM is not really convenient. We always need to estimate whether this framework fits our project well.
The other, more basic example, which can explain why we should abandon the idea of using SCRUM in some projects, also Data Science ones, is plane construction. The reason here is a lack of possibility of customers’ feedback. We have to make our plane safe, convenient, and flying. We cannot build just its carcass and ask the customer for its opinion and desirable changes. The customer will risk their life to estimate it. Here we have to work with some models similar to Waterfall: firstly to plan everything, then to make it functional and flying, then to test it multiple times and only after to start thinking about customer comfort and not to try working on all those steps at the same time. The same problem we stalk in the case of developing Data Science and other software sometimes. Firstly, we need to make a software that performs the task, then to test it and only after to improve its user convenience. So, one of the main reasons when SCRUM sucks is when customers cannot provide needed feedback.

Is Kanban the right thing to choose?
First of all, Kanban always wins when we have to have a chance to insert changes at any time or to change the priorities of tasks in our project. Kanban makes it realizable if it is needed, for example, if we have no data for the exact estimation of time needed. However, there is a range of things that Kanban cannot deal with. If you are going to use Kanban to avoid retrospectives, deadlines, interaction within a team, or dealing with tasks of different values. All these points are necessary and important for Kanban as well as for SCRUM. You still have to be able to analyze what should be changed in the future. Without a hard-working stable team, no good result can be obtained. Furthermore, when SCRUM demands us to set deadlines when there are no of them in Kanban, but we have to be ready to make a release at any time. Another key point is that tasks shouldn’t variate in value too much, instead, we have to be able to divide them into smaller tasks. Our team has to have a shared view on the project and we should work on this same vision really hard. We shouldn’t push our team to work with Kanban, but it needs to understand the key principles of that framework and realize the necessity for the work to be done by that approach. Otherwise, despite Kanban's simplicity, we cannot provide productive work by that method.

Conclusion
As such, Agile approaches lead us to be able to make any changes that depend on the environment. However, it demands great time management and interaction within a team. So, it is not only the problem that our team should be ready and well-prepared to use it, but also we face the problem that we need to develop a deep understanding if this or another framework really fits our needs and can solve our problems.










Today's News

October 8, 2021

iGavel Auctions Autumn Asian Art Sale now open for bidding

Michelangelo's David not censored at Expo, officials say

Sotheby's to sell late Botticelli masterpiece for $40+ million in January 2022

The Van Gogh Museum opens 'The Potato Eaters: Mistake or Masterpiece?'

Phillips to offer rare painting by Georgia O'Keeffe

Looking close at the fragile beauty of Chinese painting

Landmark Frida Kahlo exhibition opens in the Netherlands

Tanzanian-born novelist Abdulrazak Gurnah wins Nobel Literature Prize

Dep Art Gallery opens an exhibition devoted to the works of Imi Knoebel

Pace Gallery announces installation of monumental Joel Shapiro sculpture at the historic IBM Building

Billy Apple, artist who was his own life's work, dies at 85

Google Arts & Culture launches 'Klimt vs. Klimt: The Man of Contradictions'

Tina Turner sells music rights to BMG

Rodrigo Moynihan now represented by David Nolan Gallery

Winnie-the-Pooh bridge fetches over £130,000 at UK auction

Signed page from Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's 'Hound of the Baskervilles' finds home in Heritage manuscripts event

The Wellin Museum of Art presents the exhibition 'Sarah Oppenheimer: Sensitive Machine'

Venus Over Manhattan opens its first solo exhibition of work by the Polish artist and cult figure Maryan

Exhibition at Heller Gallery reflects on twenty years of Lino Tagliapietra's practice

Their downtown hits are now sharing a Broadway stage

Their Thai cave rescue film was done. Then 87 hours of footage arrived.

Gorgeous Galle vases lead the way in Neue Auctions' Art & Antiques Auction

Review: Carnegie Hall reopens with a blaze from Philadelphia

Exhibition features eight projects by a new generation of Chinese architects

What Agile framework should we choose?

Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy Cost is Expensive or Cheap

Five Ways Playing Online Casino is Better than the Real Thing

TBC Hunter Guide

Why Is Amazon the Top Contender to Stream NFL Sunday Ticket?

5 Tips for Taking Artistic Talent to the Next Level




Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 



Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org juncodelavega.com facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful