NEW YORK, NY.- As a young girl growing up in colonial Algeria, Marnia Lazreg was enjoined by her grandmother to wear a veil, to protect herself. Lazreg refused. She didnt feel the need for such protection, and the veil wouldnt provide it anyway.
Decades later, as a Hunter College sociologist, she looked more deeply into an aspect of Muslim society that had haunted her since that childhood moment: Was the veil imposed on women really necessary, from either a religious or a security perspective?
The answer she came up with in a collection of five essays, Questioning the Veil: Open Letters to Muslim Women, published in 2009, was the same she had given her grandmother so many years before: a firm negative.
Lazreg died Jan. 13 in New York City. She was 83.
Her death, in a hospital where she was being treated for cancer, was confirmed by her son Ramsi Woodcock.
Lazregs academic work revolved around the difficult history of her native land, which has struggled to free itself from the legacy of colonialism, the heritage of its bloody war of liberation against France, and the six decades of authoritarian rule still stifling it rule that she, as a dedicated anti-colonialist, was careful not to criticize overtly.
In books that also explored Algerian class structure (The Emergence of Classes in Algeria, 1976) and the use of torture by imperial powers (Torture and the Twilight of Empire, 2008), among other subjects, Lazreg grappled with both the complicated heritage of domination by France and the internal conflicts arising in Muslim societies.
Though not widely reviewed and often laced with academic jargon, Lazregs books were unusual because she herself was unusual: an Algerian-born scholar, from a working-class background, based in America and writing in English, from a feminist, anti-colonial perspective.
Like other Algerian intellectuals, she was haunted by the continuing hold over her country of the colonial power, France, against which Algerias nationhood had shaped itself.
In contemporary Algeria, France remains an obsession. Lazreg was not immune.
The only thing this Algerian wants is that we be left alone, that we be left to be, without having to remind you, French intellectuals and politicians, that we dont belong to you, that we never belonged to you, she said in an interview with the Algerian news website Toute Sur lAlgerie in 2009. So busy yourself with your own problems. Algeria is no longer one of them.
Yet her work was shaped by this twisted relationship. Writing about Algeria is an endless discovery of a history I was never taught, she wrote in the Journal of World Philosophies in 2020.
Thinking I would come to terms with the colonial legacy, I first studied the emergence of social classes in the aftermath of the war of decolonization in Algeria, Lazreg continued. She concluded that classes under the countrys regime at the time, which styled itself socialist, would emancipate themselves from their dependency on the state.
That argument, though, turned out to be incorrect in a country where everything, from business to social and intellectual life, still depends on the state.
She was very anti-colonial, and I think that made her reluctant to take too hard a line against the Algerian government, for fear of feeding Western narratives, Woodcock, her son, said in an interview. She was always very proud of Algerian independence.
Perhaps her best-known work was Questioning the Veil, in which she pushed back against the idea that the Muslim faith requires it, or that it represents an authentic expression of choice for women.
Denial of a womans physical body helps to sustain the fiction that veiling it, covering it up, causes no harm to the woman who inhabits the body, Lazreg wrote.
She suggested that social pressure from men was behind much of the push to re-veil. She recounted the poignant anecdote of a young woman whose systematic beating by her brother stopped only when she put on the veil.
Nonetheless, and in spite of these findings, she always wanted to avoid playing into Western narratives that Islam is misogynistic, Woodcock said. On the one hand she was anti-colonialist, but she was also a feminist. It was a tightrope she always had to walk.
The Economist called the book uneven and with a rather weak grasp of French secularism, but nonetheless said it had great merit. Other judgments in the book have not worn so well, for instance her criticism of the American-sponsored constitutions of both Afghanistan and Iraq, which she said were lauded as protecting the rights of women in spite of evidence to the contrary.
Lazregs abiding concern with colonialism spilled over into her 2008 book on torture, which in her vision became a kind of matrix for colonial society: The history of torture becomes synonymous with the history of colonialism and war, with modern history itself, historian Priya Satia wrote in a review in The Times Literary Supplement in 2009. In Lazregs ethical vision, colonialism itself is a kind of torture chamber.
Among Lazregs other books was a novel, The Awakening of the Mother (2019); The Eloquence of Silence: Algerian Women in Question (1994); Foucaults Orient (2017), a critique of historian and philosopher Michel Foucault; and Islamic Feminism and the Discourse of Post-Liberation (2021).
Marnia Lazreg was born Jan. 10, 1941, in the Algerian coastal city of Mostaganem, east of the capital, Algiers, to Aoued Lazreg, who had a dry goods shop in the citys market, and Fatima (Ghrib) Lazreg.
Through chance and good luck, Marnia Lazreg was able to attend a French school and obtain a baccalauréat degree the equivalent of a high school diploma even as Algeria was fighting for its independence, in 1960. It was a rare achievement for an Algerian woman at that time.
She received a degree in English literature from the University of Algiers in 1966, and, because of her proficiency in English she had studied English obsessively as a way of resistance against the French, her son said she became a valued recruit for the state oil firm, Sonatrach, which has recently been mired in corruption scandals.
In 1966 she opened Sonatrachs first office in the U.S., in Rockefeller Center in Manhattan. She began attending classes at New York University and earned a doctorate in sociology there in 1974.
Alongside her academic career, Lazreg worked in international development for the World Bank and the United Nations, with a focus on womens issues. She helped coordinate World Bank efforts to bring women into lending programs in Eastern Europe and Central Asia, and she was a consultant to the U.N. on development programs.
After an earlier teaching stint at Hunter College and spells at Sarah Lawrence and Hampshire, she returned to Hunter full time in 1988. She also taught at the City University of New York Graduate Center.
In addition to her son Ramsi Woodcock, Lazreg is survived by another son, Reda Woodcock, and a granddaughter. An earlier marriage ended in divorce.
After she received her baccalauréat, her son said, Lazreg had taught for a time in what were called native schools a limited opening toward the future. Algerias independence in 1962, he added, opened up a new world for her.
That experience of liberation was transformative for her, he said, adding that it led her to bat away complaints about the long decades of oppressive rule Algerians have suffered under since then. She would say: Look, were free. You cant put a price on that.
This article originally appeared in
The New York Times.