In a world of visual overload, the key question is: who decides what constitutes art? This is one of the central questions in the contemporary art world. This is where international competitions and their juries come into play. They increasingly function as a filter, helping us understand what is new, high-quality, and significant in the visual arts.
In recent years, something has changed: works are now evaluated not only by curators and theorists, but also by the artists themselves. This is because the industry needs a deeper perspective from those who create.
One expert whose work serves as a benchmark is photographer Bella Beishembaeva, who, thanks to her professionalism, victories at international exhibitions, and standing within the professional community, was invited to join the expert jury of the international Arteno Art Award. This competition brings together artists from more than 50 countries around the world who demonstrate technical mastery, conceptual depth, and innovation. The more than 10,000 submissions speak for themselves regarding the competitions recognition in the creative world.
Bella Beishembaeva established herself as an artist at a time when the image became ubiquitous. In her works, which blend fashion photography and conceptual portraits, she explores emotions and self-perception through composition, light, and color. Her approach is based on perceiving the image as a holistic system, where every element contributes to the final result.
Anyone can take a photo these days, but that doesnt mean it automatically becomes art, says Bella Beishembaeva. Professional artistic work is evaluated on a point system based on specific criteria; its important to consider artistic vision, originality, and technical skill. Aesthetic harmony, as well as cultural and emotional impact, are also important.
At Arteno, Beishembaeva serves on the jury to select entries, compile a shortlist of finalists, and make the crucial decision in determining the winner.
The competition helps define future industry standards and identify industry leaders. When you review hundreds of entries one after another, you start to notice the same approaches, themes, and techniques. And this is where its important to discern where a mere fashion trend ends and something truly professional and original begins.
Serenity. Photograph by B. Beishembaeva
Bella Beishembaeva has participated in numerous projects; her works were selected and presented at the international exhibition Emotional Echoes in Italy. This experience helps her view competitions from different perspectives. She says this experience greatly influences how she approaches evaluating works.
I know very well what its like when your work is first presented to the publicits very vulnerable, she says. Thats why its extremely important for me to treat the artist with respect, even if the competitions criteria differ from the artists original vision.
Competitions like Arteno are not just a place to showcase work. They are also a space where professional dialogue takes place. And in this dialogue, the artist-expert plays a special role: they bridge the gap between creative practice and critical reflection.
For me, the most important thing is to determine how cohesive the work is, and to what extent its message meets the criteria and is justified and logical within the work itself. Evaluation is never a matter of personal taste, Beishembaeva emphasizes.
Its also worth discussing how evaluation criteria need to be adapted to new art forms. Today, works often dont fit solely within the framework of conventional photography; they may incorporate video, 3D graphics, or even performances.
We are increasingly seeing works that cannot be attributed to any single category, says Beishembaeva. Flexibility is needed here. You cant evaluate such projects by old standards, but at the same time, its important to remember the basics: integrity, logic, and clarity of what the author wants to say.
The fact that Beishembaeva was invited to serve on the jury confirms her recognition by the professional community and highlights her personal achievements. It also reflects that the industry is seeking a new type of expertthose who can work at the intersection of different disciplines.
For Bella herself, serving on the jury is like a continuation of her work, but in a different role.
When you create your own work, you invent your own language, she says. But when youre on the jury, you start to notice how different languages interact. This helps you understand what possibilities photography actually holds.
Harmony. Photograph by B. Beishembaeva
Bella Beishembaeva is noteworthy not only for her artistic work, but also because she herself is actively involved in these processes. The way she has transitioned from the role of creator to that of expert reflects profound changes in visual culture: artists now not only create but also actively participate in broader conversations and decision-making within the art world.
It is precisely at this intersectionbetween creation and evaluation, between personal vision and general rulesthat a new approach to expertise in art is now emerging. And the participation of artists like Beishembaeva in international juries is one of the most striking examples of these changes.
We now live in a time when the photograph has become an everyday part of our communication, she concludes. And perhaps today the experts task is not so much to choose the best as it is to help us see where there is real meaning in this flow.