A quartet sets a new standard for Beethoven marathons

The First Art Newspaper on the Net    Established in 1996 Thursday, April 25, 2024


A quartet sets a new standard for Beethoven marathons
The Danish String Quartet — from left, Rune Tonsgaard Sorensen, Frederik Oland, Asbjorn Norgaard and Fredrik Schoyen Sjolin — preform at Alice Tully Hall in New York, Feb. 12, 2020. The Danish String Quartet presented Beethoven’s complete quartets over six extraordinary concerts at Alice Tully Hall. James Estrin/The New York Times.

by Anthony Tommasini



NEW YORK (NYT NEWS SERVICE ).- Almost 15 years ago, the men of the Danish String Quartet — they were in their 20s at the time and still called themselves the “Young” Danish — said in an interview that they would need to become more mature before daring to play Beethoven’s late string quartets in public.

It didn’t take that long for these prodigiously gifted musicians to get over their youthful reticence. In 2014, for their first Chamber Music Society of Lincoln Center performance at Alice Tully Hall, they ended a program with an urgent yet cogent, spacious and mystical account of the Quartet in A minor (Op. 132). And they were back there this month for a series of six concerts, again presented by the society, devoted to all 16 of Beethoven’s quartets performed in chronological order.

Over the years, the Danish quartet has played these pieces individually. But this is only the second time they attempted a daunting complete cycle — about nine hours of music. Tully was packed for all six programs, which opened Feb. 7 and concluded Tuesday. This year, the 250th anniversary of Beethoven’s birth, is going to offer lots of complete cycles. It’s always difficult to bring fresh takes to pervasively familiar repertory, but the standard set by this quartet will be especially hard to top.

As a rule, I’m not keen on complete Beethoven cycles, precisely because these scores remain such fixtures of our musical lives. I prefer programs that take on Beethoven by juxtaposing his pieces with works by other composers. That’s the approach the Danish quartet took in two recent recordings on the ECM label, “Prism I” and “Prism II,” which place two late Beethoven quartets in context with Bach fugues and 20th-century quartets by Shostakovich and Schnittke.

But perhaps Beethoven’s string quartets could benefit from being heard complete if they’re in order, spanning the composer’s career. And how many opportunities do we get to hear, say, the “Serioso” Quartet?

Or, for that matter, the six early quartets published together as Op. 18. For all the command these probing musicians demonstrated in their riveting accounts of the late quartets, their excellence came through most in bracing performances of the early works.

Beethoven modeled those Op. 18 quartets on Haydn, his teacher, who essentially invented the genre of string quartet. Here Beethoven was honoring him by writing works within the protocols of form and style that Haydn had developed. But there is an element of one-upmanship at play. Beethoven is taking on the master, showing what, in a sense, a “Haydn” quartet could really be.

There was an impish quality in the Danish quartet’s playing, despite its elegance and brilliance. From the first phrase of the opening work, the Quartet in D (Op. 18, No. 3), the blissfully lyrical violin melody, soaring over seemingly supportive harmonies in the other strings, sounded cozy and alluring but just a touch sly. Sure enough, before long, an episode of spiraling passages in triples seemed like a warning for us to listen below the sunny surface.

It’s difficult to explain what makes the Danish String Quartet’s playing so special. Other ensembles arguably match these players in technical excellence and interpretive insight. To say that their performances represent a marvelous balancing of qualities suggests that they occupy some place in the middle of the road. The results are anything but: There is a winning mix of studied concentration and willful freedom in their playing. “All Scandinavians feel like they have a bit of an anarchist inside them,” Asbjorn Norgaard, the group’s violist, said in a 2016 interview. That came through during this entire series.

Their technical command resulted in precise execution. Yet they played with enough leeway to allow instinctive responses to take over in the moment. You might assume that musicians in their 30s would bring youthful energy to bear, but I was struck by how often they opted for a raptly restrained tempo. Rhythms were dispatched with clarity and exactitude without a trace of rigidity.

They have a shared sensibility and richly blended sound. But that doesn’t stop their individual musical characters from continuously shining through. (The members, besides Norgaard, are Frederik Oland and Rune Tonsgaard Sorensen, who trade playing first and second violin parts, and Fredrik Schoyen Sjolin, a Norwegian cellist who has been with the ensemble since 2008.)

The big endurance test of the cycle was the third program, in which they played the three “Razumovsky” Quartets (Op. 59), from 1806. Here is the towering Beethoven, the composer as revolutionary, striding across the pages of these scores — brash, adventurous and ingenious. I found the performance here of the middle one, in E minor, especially distinguished. The Danish quartet brought out both the brooding weightiness and near-crazed intensity of the music. The ebullient third, in C, ends with a quasi-fugue finale, a breathlessly fast tour de force with streams of rapid-fire notes. For an encore, they repeated the final large section of that movement. And, with nothing to prove, they played with an extra dose of daring.

It’s hard to single out movements, or even moments, from the ensemble’s accounts of the late quartets. I loved how they began the Quartet No. 12 in E-flat (Op. 127), which opens with what seems a fanfare, in thick chords, that soon spins off into a genial exploration of a winding theme. The Danish quartet underlined this passage with grit and urgency that sent a signal: A gate to a new path had been opened.

They ended the Quartet No. 13 in B-flat (Op. 130) with the original finale, the Grosse Fuge, not the benign substitute Beethoven replaced it with at the urging of his publisher. That section still comes across like the fugue to end all fugues, with outbursts of sputtering rhythms, obsessively hammered attacks and tangles of wayward counterpoint. As played here, it sounded audacious, extreme and, finally, exhilarating.

The players showed imagination in closing programs with short encores, including a harmonically juiced-up arrangement of Beethoven’s popular piano piece “Für Elise” and, on Valentine’s Day, “My Funny Valentine.” But after the series ended Tuesday with the Quartet in F (Op. 135), they returned to the stage without their instruments, joined arms shoulder-to-shoulder and smiled to the cheering audience. They gave Beethoven the last word. Which was right.

© 2020 The New York Times Company










Today's News

February 21, 2020

Shipwreck yields artifacts of missing seafarers in Canada's Arctic

Berlin court jails three over 100-kg gold coin heist

The Cleveland Museum of Art receives 62 works from the collection of Mark Schwartz + Bettina Katz

Sale of the Donald B. Marron Family Collection to be handled by Acquavella Galleries, Gagosian and Pace Gallery

With final Gracie Mansion show, First Lady aims to secure arts legacy

Archives on controversial war-time Pope Pius XII set to open

24th annual McNay Print Fair features thousands of prints, watercolors, photographs, and drawings

Art Basel launches Online Viewing Rooms

Christie's London to offer Property from Chieveley House, Berkshire and five private collections

Rare Ethiopian crown, hidden for 21 years in the Netherlands, returns home

High-quality decorative arts from private collections featured in Koller's March auctions

Controversial director back at Bolshoi to shatter opera cliches

Forensic Architecture founder says United States denied him a visa

Esther Scott, 'Boyz N the Hood' actress, dies at 66

Foam opens an exhibition of works by Sheng-Wen Lo

Freeman's achieves record for Edgar Degas cast post 1948

Venice Biennale headliner Narine Arakelian celebrated Frieze L.A. in MASH Gallery's riotous À GOGO show

Steven Parrino retrospective opens at Kunstmuseum Liechtenstein

How do you follow an It bag?

Edward Tyler Nahem opens a solo exhibition of the late American painter Kenneth Victor Young

Jean-François Millet leads Prints & Drawings at Swann

Estate of trailblazer and icon Diahann Carroll to be auctioned at Bonhams Los Angeles

A quartet sets a new standard for Beethoven marathons

'Salvador Dalí: Gardens of the Mind' opens at Marie Selby Botanical Gardens

Los Angeles Modern Auctions sets new auction records at February auction

How Busy Entrepreneurs Can Stay On Track With Their Fitness Goals

How To Design An Art Studio To Your Liking




Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 



Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org juncodelavega.com facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful