The First Art Newspaper on the Net    Established in 1996 Tuesday, July 5, 2022

Napoleon's Mideast campaign still contentious, two centuries on
A museum worker walks in a hall in Qasr al-Basha in Gaza City on April 21, 2021, where Napoleon Bonaparte slept for several nights during his campaign in Egypt and Palestine.. Napoleon Bonaparte's bloody campaign in Egypt and Palestine, which marked the start of modern European colonialism in the Middle East, remains contentious two centuries after the French emperor's death. The Corsican general set sail eastwards with 300 ships in 1798, aiming to conquer Egypt and block a crucial route between Britain and its colonies in India. Emmanuel DUNAND / AFP.

by Emmanuel Parisse with Guillaume Lavallee in Gaza

CAIRO (AFP).- Napoleon Bonaparte's bloody campaign in Egypt and Palestine, which marked the start of modern European colonialism in the Middle East, remains contentious two centuries after the French emperor's death.

The Corsican general set sail eastwards with 300 ships in 1798, aiming to conquer Egypt and block a crucial route between Britain and its colonial territories in India.

It was an occupation that was to leave thousands dead in Egypt and Palestine.

But Bonaparte also brought some 160 scholars and engineers, who produced mountains of research that would play a key role in transforming Egypt into a modern state.

For Egyptian writer Mohamed Salmawy, speaking ahead of the May 5 bicentenary of Napoleon's death, the venture was a mix of "fire and light".

"It was a military campaign, for sure, and Egyptians put up resistance to French forces. But it was also the start of an era of intellectual progress," he said.

The "Description de l'Egypte" resulting from the mission was an encyclopaedic account of Egypt's society, history, fauna and flora.

French troops' discovery of the Rosetta Stone also allowed hieroglyphs to be deciphered for the first time, opening up the field of Egyptology.

Ruler Mohamed Ali drew heavily on Napoleonic research as he built the modern Egyptian state, says French-Egyptian writer Robert Sole.

But Arab nationalist Gamal Abdel Nasser, who helped topple Mohamed Ali's dynasty in 1952, used the episode to promote an anti-colonial national identity.

For historian Al-Hussein Hassan Hammad, at Cairo's Al-Azhar University, Napoleon's scientists were, like his troops, on an imperial mission "to serve the French presence in Egypt... and exploit its wealth."


When Bonaparte's fleet anchored in 1798 close to Alexandria, he ordered soldiers to daub walls with the message: "Egyptians, you will be told that I am coming to destroy your religion: it is a lie, do not believe it!"

But his claims of religious tolerance soon gave way to repression after he toppled the centuries-old Mamluk dynasty in July 1798.

When Egyptians revolted against their occupiers that October, French troops brutally crushed the uprising.

They killed thousands and even bombed the Al-Azhar mosque, a key authority for Sunni Muslims worldwide.

Many Egyptians today see the episode as "the first imperialist aggression of the modern age against the Muslim Orient", Sole said.

That sentiment is echoed in the neighbouring Gaza Strip.

Napoleon seized the ancient port city with little resistance in February 1799, having marched through the Sinai desert after British admiral Horatio Nelson destroyed his fleet.

"He is a small man who has caused great chaos in this region," said Ghassan Wisha, head of history at the Islamic University of Gaza.

"Napoleon came here not only with soldiers but also with scientists and agricultural specialists. But he used science to justify the occupation. He lied."

'Dark, negative image'

Rashad al-Madani, a retired Gaza history lecturer, said the city had been "a centre for honey, oil and agriculture, and a strategic point between Asia and Europe".

Napoleon wrote that Gaza's hills, covered with "forests of olive trees", reminded him of Languedoc in southern France.

Two centuries on, those groves have given way to a forest of concrete.

Gaza is home to two million Palestinians, many of them refugees, ruled by Islamist movement Hamas and strangled by an Israeli blockade.

Madani would remind his students of Napoleon's massacre of some 3,000 people in the port town of Jaffa further up the coast.

"The French occupation was worse than that of Israel," he said.

Small reminders of Napoleon remain in Gaza.

The Qasr al-Basha, the Pasha's Palace where the emperor-to-be reportedly stayed, still stands.

It is a modest sandstone edifice surrounded by scruffy concrete buildings and electric wires.

The palace, first built in the 13th century, had long born Napoleon's name.

But tellingly, after Islamist movement Hamas seized power in Gaza in 2007, it changed the name.

The palace has become a museum, and the first-floor bedroom where the general stayed, unfurnished today, is filled with Byzantine artefacts.

"The population of Gaza today has a dark, negative image of all military campaigns, including that of Napoleon," said Wisha.

'Still sensitive'

It was in Acre, a sleepy port town further north, that Palestinians found a local hero in the struggle against Napoleon.

Ahmad al-Jazzar is still admired by many for holding out for two months against a crushing French siege.

"In our history books, Ahmad al-Jazzar is seen as a strong character, a hero," said Madani.

But Jazzar -- Arabic for "butcher" -- was also "a cruel being, an aggressor," he said.

"Many students didn't like it when I told them that."

And the Arab leader's French rival sparks similar strong reactions.

Marianne Khoury, the executive producer of Egyptian Youssef Chahine's film Adieu Bonaparte, said Napoleon's campaign was still "excessively controversial".

For many in France, the 1985 film was "unacceptable", she said.

"How could Chahine as an Arab director dare to talk about Bonaparte?"

Some Egyptians, for their part, recognise the scientific progress the French invasion brought.

"But the same time, there is the colonial aspect, which is still sensitive, and many Egyptians don't accept it," she said.

© Agence France-Presse

Today's News

May 3, 2021

Hermann Historica GmbH distinguished mementos from ruling houses

The Botín Centre explores the influence of Iberian art on the work of Pablo Picasso

Hindman Auctions to present Spring Fine Books and Manuscripts Including Americana sale

Escher exhibition on view at the Columbia Museum of Art

Maruani Mercier presents works celebrating the power of an inspiring and highly symbolic colour: Black

Sotheby's and Phillips announce departures and arrivals

Worldwide David Hockney digital artwork on view in Times Square, London, Seoul, and Tokyo

David Zwirner opens two concurrent exhibitions of new work by Carol Bove

Recent acquisitions on display at the Morris Museum of Art

Christie's France announces a sale dedicated to women artists

Almine Rech Brussels opens two new exhibitions

Christie's announces highlights included in the Chinese Ceramics and Works of Art auctions

Jill Newhouse and Mireille Mosler to present exhibitions of 19th/20th works on paper and paintings

MAGMA gallery pens the first solo exhibition of Amandine Urruty in Italy

Asia Society Texas opens "The Mountain That Does Not Describe a Circle: Works by Hong Hong"

Napoleon's Mideast campaign still contentious, two centuries on

James Prigoff, who documented street art, dies at 93

UCCA announces appointment of Peter Eleey as Curator-at-Large

Anne Douglas, widow of Hollywood legend Kirk, dies at 102

M 2 3 opens an exhibition of recent work by Amina Ross, Chadwick Rantanen, Sean Donovan

Works by Nydia Blas and Devin Troy Strother join the permanent collection of the California African American Museum

Freeman's to bring Sylvia Shaw Judson's Bird Girl to auction for the first time

Christie's announces Handbags and Accessories live auction in Hong Kong

Mudam Luxembourg presents over two hundred images from the Archive of Modern Conflict

Baccarat and Online Football Betting

Drug and Alcohol Treatment: A Brief Guide to Rehab

5 Tips to Stimulate Your Senses from Home

Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .


Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez

Royalville Communications, Inc
Founder's Site. Hommage
to a Mexican poet.

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful