France scoffs at an Englishman's 'Napoleon'

The First Art Newspaper on the Net    Established in 1996 Wednesday, April 17, 2024


France scoffs at an Englishman's 'Napoleon'
The Rosetta Stone, at the British Museum in London on Feb. 3, 2017. Scholars say that a trailer for Ridley Scott’s new film draws attention to the French emperor’s complex and lasting legacy on the study of Egypt’s cultural heritage. (Tom Jamieson/The New York Times)

Catherine Porter



PARIS.- The French do not like an Englishman’s rendition of Napoleon.

Or at least, the French critics do not.

Looking grim and moody from under an enormous bicorn hat, Joaquin Phoenix glowers from posters around Paris, promoting the film by Ridley Scott that offers the latest reincarnation of the French hero whose nose — as one reviewer deliciously wrote — still rises in the middle of French political life two centuries after his death.

Yet while British and American reviewers glowed, French critics considered it lazy, pointless, boring, migraine-inducing, too short and historically inaccurate. And that’s just to start.

The critic for the left-wing daily Libération panned the film as not just ugly, but vacuous, positing nothing and “very sure of its inanity.” The review in Le Monde offered that if the director’s vision had one merit, it was “simplicity” — “a montage alternating between Napoleon’s love life and his feats of battle.”

The right-wing Le Figaro took many positions in its breathless coverage, using the moment to pump out a 132-page special-edition magazine on Napoleon, along with more than a dozen articles, including a reader poll and a Napoleon knowledge test. The newspaper’s most memorable take came from Thierry Lentz, director of the Napoleon Foundation, a charity dedicated to historical research: He considered Phoenix’s version of Napoleon — compared with more than 100 other actors who have played the role — “a bit vulgar, a bit rude, with a voice from elsewhere that doesn’t fit at all.”

All of this was to be expected.

As French writer Sylvain Tesson once famously said, “France is a paradise inhabited by people who think they’re in hell.” How else would you expect a country where the perennial response to “How are you?” is “Not bad” to respond to a historical film about itself?

But to have that film be about a French legend — even one whom many detest — played by an American actor and directed by a British filmmaker?

L’horreur.

“This very anti-French and very pro-English film is, however, not very ‘English’ in spirit,” said historian Patrick Gueniffey in Le Point magazine, “because the English have never compromised their admiration for their enemy.”

“It’s hard not to see this hasty approach as the historical revenge of Ridley Scott, the Englishman,” assessed satirical weekly Le Canard Enchaîné. “An Austerlitz of cinema? More like Waterloo.”

Bracing under the waterfall of negative reaction, you begin to wonder whether the criticism reveals more about the French psyche than the nation’s taste in historical cinema.

“When we talk about Napoleon, in fact we are getting at the heart of our principles and our political divisions,” explained Arthur Chevallier, a Napoleon expert who has published five books on the Corsican soldier who seized power after the French Revolution, crowned himself emperor and proceeded to conquer — and later lose — much of Western Europe.

“The common point among all French people is that Napoleon remains a subject that influences our understanding of ourselves, our identity,” Chevallier said.




More than 200 years after his death, the smudges of Napoleon’s fingerprints still liberally decorate the country and its capital: along the streets and metro stations named after his generals and battles; from atop the Arc de Triomphe that he planned; and in the gleam of the gold dome of the Invalides, under which his giant marble tomb rises.

Lawyers still follow an updated version of his civil code. Provincial regions are still overseen by prefects — or government administrators — in a system he devised. Every year, high schoolers take the baccalaureate exam that his regime introduced, and citizens are awarded the country’s top honor, which he invented.

Last Sunday, before the film hit theaters here, a French auction house announced that it had sold one of Napoleon’s signature bicorn hats for a record 1.9 million euros, or $2.1 million.

In recent decades, Napoleon’s record for misogyny, imperialism and racism — he reimposed slavery eight years after the revolutionary government abolished it — has come under glaring critical light. But that seems to have simply reinforced the weight of his legacy.

To many, Napoleon is the symbol of a France that has come under assault from what they consider an American import of identity politics and “wokeism.” The latest front page of weekly far-right magazine Valeurs Actuelles declared him “The Anti-Woke Emperor.” (Its reviewer also panned the film: From the first scene, the viewer knows that “historical accuracy will suffer the guillotine,” wrote Laurent Dandrieu.)

In a national poll conducted this week, 74% of respondents with an opinion on Napoleon considered his actions beneficial for France.

“You have the impression that when we talk about him, he’s a living politician,” said Chevallier, who has already seen the film twice and counts himself among its few unabashed French fans.

What he liked, he said, was its different take on Napoleon and the revolution that birthed him and modern France. Instead of a regal leader with insatiable energy and ambition, Phoenix portrays a regular grasping mortal who is the product of a bloodthirsty, barbaric upheaval — something that some find “very destabilizing,” Chevallier said, but that he considered interesting and instructive, “because you understand why Napoleon inspired such hate” among other European powers at the time.

He predicted that his fellow citizens who were more cinema fans than history buffs would like the film, which opened to the public Wednesday.

Some 120,000 people went to see it across France that day — a strong opening, but not a blockbuster like “Asterix & Obelix: The Middle Kingdom,” which drew more than 460,000 on its opening day early this year, according to figures collected by CBO Box Office, a firm that collates French box office data.

Moviegoers streaming out of a theater in the Latin Quarter of Paris on Thursday night were not enthused.

Augustin Ampe, 20, said he was all for demystifying Napoleon, but this was just too much. “Here he looks like a clumsy man focused only on his wife,” said the literature student, breaking for a moment from a fierce debate over the film’s failures with his friends. He preferred the mythical figure offered in the books and poems of Chateaubriand and Victor Hugo, he said.

Waiting for her movie date to finish his post-film cigarette, Charline Tartar, a librarian, assessed Phoenix’s rendition as too moan-y.

“It’s too bad Napoleon looks like a loser,” said Tartar, 27. She thought a French director would have paid more attention to historical accuracy.

“The French,” she added, “are very jealous of their history.”

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.










Today's News

November 29, 2023

After 9 years in limbo, treasures from Crimea return to Ukraine

Leighton's iconic Victorian painting, Flaming June, to be shown at the Royal Academy of Arts

La Belle Epoque Auction House presents " Holiday Season Multi-Estates" live auction December 2nd

Two paintings by Pietro Lorenzetti, major artist of the early 14th century Sienese School of painting, rediscovered

France scoffs at an Englishman's 'Napoleon'

Coins, tokens and medals from the Isaac Rudman Collection fetch £93,760 at Noonans

Major international exhibition 'Self-Determination: A Global Perspective' now on view at Irish Museum of Modern Art

60 Years of Gallery Chemould 'CheMoulding: Framing Future Archives' curated by Shaleen Wadhwana now open

New and recent work by American sculptor Tom Friedman being exhibited by Lehmann Maupin

Two-venue exhibition curated by Robert Storr 'Retinal Hysteria' on view at Venus Over Manhattan

'Gone Wild' Mario Testino's third exhibition with Hamiltons is now showing

Historic Palazzo Donarelli Ricci is now new location for Tim Van Laere Gallery in Rome

Auction at Drouot offers a glimpse into the world of one of France's greatest composers

Duygu Demir appointed curator at The NYU Abu Dhabi Art Gallery

Royal College of Art appoints Professor Christoph Lindner as new President and Vice-Chancellor

Works by N.C. Wyeth, Jaune Quick-to-See Smith and Ernie Barnes soar past their estimates at Heritage

David Rappeneau's first Asia show now open at Gladstone Gallery

Art and entertainment luminaries join design innovators in a star-studded lineup at Blackwell Auctions

'Running' solo exhibition by Nour Malas presented by Carbon 12 now on view

Linus Borgo's debut solo exhibition 'Monstrum' in New York to open at Yossi Milo

Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie, who looked at history from the bottom up, dies at 94

Almine Rech now represents Tia Thuy Nguyen

China Vigorously Promotes Poverty Reduction and Development in Africa (New Era of China-Africa Cooperation)

7 Things You Can Do to Extend the Life of Your Garage Door

What is Resveratrol and Its Amazing Health Benefits?

What Kind of Art is Best for Your Zodiac Sign to Persue

Mastering Web Design Fundamentals: A Deep Dive into the CSS Box Model




Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 



Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org juncodelavega.com facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful