NEW YORK, NY.- In the early 1990s, Jim White was a drumming journeyman, having pounded out rhythms in a string of loud and rabid bands with snotty names, such as Feral Dinosaurs or Venom P. Stinger. On the cusp of 30, he started Dirty Three, along with two other idiosyncratic Australian instrumentalists: violinist Warren Ellis and guitarist Mick Turner. Their lambent jams found unexpected enthusiasm inside Melbourne bars.
One afternoon during the groups early days, Eddie Midnight, the jocular brother of a friend, shouted out to White, calling him by the nickname he hated: Hey, Skins! You got a minute? I found something good for ya. Back at his house, Midnight pulled out an ash-caked snare its heads busted and one rim missing that he had spotted in a shed. White said thanks and took what he suspected was trash to a music shop. The employees were flummoxed: Where had White found this treasure, a Ludwig Black Beauty from the 1920s? It was a holy grail everywhere but a near-impossible score in Australia.
And then, White played it.
It just sounds amazing, irrefutably beautiful very dynamic, always warm, got a great crack, White said, smiling in the spartan kitchen of the Brooklyn walk-up where he has lived since 2010, on a sunny February afternoon. He extended the snare, its nickel frame mottled like an ancient mountainside. People hear it, and they say, Do you mind if I go buy one just like it?
But ask the singers with whom White has played during the past 30 years Cat Power or Nick Cave, PJ Harvey or Bill Callahan and they might agree that no one else makes that battered snare (or, really, the drums) sound quite like White. Intuitive but measured, propulsive but patient, Whites drumming has become an instantly identifiable instrumental voice, anchored by Midnights gift.
You can hear the rainbow of his emotion in the swells, the dropouts, the attacks, Chan Marshall, who records as Cat Power, said in an interview. Hes able to master the set at any time, in any situation, and its always going to be Jim White. I dont know anyone else who can do that.
After a career of making music with others, White, 62, has finished his first solo album, All Hits: Memories, out Friday. The first in a triptych of new releases that includes a duo with guitarist Marisa Anderson and the return of Dirty Three after a dozen years, Whites brief, dense record underscores what has forever driven his singular approach: a ceaseless curiosity about whats left to learn.
Hes like Albert Einstein behind a drum kit, even the way he dresses, Ellis, the Dirty Three multi-instrumentalist, said in a video interview, chuckling. (White recently lopped off his longtime Einsteinian poof, but he still dresses like a professor.) Hes a font of knowledge, always with an opinion. Jim reads a book. I regurgitate what he tells me.
When White toured with Cat Power, Marshall remembered, he would sometimes bring along mathematics tomes, devouring them as the band bounced between shows. White first balked at the memory but admitted his life plan involved studying math that is, until drumming intervened, and he dropped out of college.
The middle child and only son of a college professor and high school English teacher, White was a devoted student and shy child who slowly got swept up by rock and country Charley Pride and the Rolling Stones first, punk later. When he asked to play drums, his parents agreed to buy them only after he had stuck with lessons. His older sister, Anna, was painting, so creativity became a kind of competition to see who worked harder and practiced more.
There was a fundamental difference. My sister went into her room painting, a solitary activity, White said. But me, I liked the whole interaction part. As soon as I got a car, I was finding people.
For a half-century, thats exactly what White has done most every day. Dirty Threes open-ended improvisations provided endless runway, allowing him to develop new techniques and patterns that commingled math and emotion. Over the years, fantasy opportunities to work with childhood idols such as Lou Reed and Neil Young appeared but never materialized. Anyway, White treasured singer-songwriters who expanded that term, finding new ways to frame old feelings.
Im not saying I would have turned down Lou Reed, White said, pausing to laugh. But Cat Power and Will Oldham have these voices that do something to people, including me. If you think something is really good and you want to be involved, how much choice do you have?
Still, he has never been interested in being subsumed by singer or songwriter, in just keeping the beat. His playing on Smogs Say Valley Maker (2005) was a composition unto itself that mirrored the lyrics, rising from canter to charge; his tessellated layers on Cat Powers American Flag (1998) amplified her lyrical vertigo.
Drummers always say theyre serving the song, but whats the song, you know? Its a cop-out, he said, his gentle voice momentarily indignant. Ive got a perspective. Its like the theory of relativity where youre standing is important.
In spite of countless sessions, White never really cared about the recording process. He once owned a four-track he seldom used and could barely name a microphone. But early in 2020, after a tour with lutist George Xylouris, White stuck around Australia to help his ailing father. When pandemic curfews were announced, he rushed around Melbourne, borrowing and buying enough gear to record remotely. Turns out, nearing 60, he enjoyed becoming an engineering autodidact.
Back in the living room of his Brooklyn apartment, crowded with art and rows of sci-fi and history books, White stockpiled more gear, including keyboards. He set up his kit on a rug and began passing bits to Guy Picciotto, the former Fugazi guitarist who first met White while his band slept on the floor of the Dirty Threes Chicago label. Living on opposite sides of Brooklyns Prospect Park, the two had become close friends and collaborators. White had speculated about a solo record for years. This was different.
For musicians who are basically masters of their instrument to challenge themselves with an instrument theyve never played, thats a very bold move, Picciotto said from his Brooklyn basement. He could have made a record strictly of drums, but I was so surprised how quickly he dialed in these keyboards. Thats the thing thats so fun about working with him: Theres no reticence. Its always Lets try!
All Hits: Memories resembles a playground, each of its 13 short tracks suggesting an adventure into an idea. Mostly devoid of percussion, Soft Material uses electronics to conjure an angels sigh. The clatter of Walking the Block is a bracing snapshot of big-city tizzies, a fanfare for energy itself. But the most intriguing bit may be St. Francis Place Set Up, a 58-second tour of Whites drum kit interrupted by a warm piano chord. As a warped sample of the piano loops, that prized old snare holds the center.
Long in the works, Dirty Threes soon-to-be-announced album finds the trio as expansive and open as ever, shifting from ragged and twisted instrumental punk glory to slow hymns that feel like haunted dreams and back.
Almost two decades ago, the band flew into Portugal. White waited impatiently at the luggage carousel for the plastic shell that protected his treasured snare. It never arrived, so he returned every day to ask. When his patience finally faded, he crossed the security line and was almost arrested. An officer took pity, though, and escorted him to the luggage hold a tin shed with a dirt floor.
I found it there in a corner in the dark, away from everything, he said, beaming as if talking about spotting a missing pet. Ive never checked it since.
On occasion, White runs into Midnight or hears from someone who has. Hell say that maybe its time to have the snare back or get paid for the treasure. Is it a joke? Regardless, White laughed, not a chance. Any time you want to come to a show or whatever, OK, he said about Midnights recompense. If I play another drum, I still sound like me. But I just want to play mine, because Im happy with it.
This article originally appeared in
The New York Times.